Skip to content
Home » Latest Articles » The NSW Police: results from the 9th February commission.

The NSW Police: results from the 9th February commission.

Australian policing is once again officially exposed for the brutal repression it perpetrates on the Australian masses. The NSW court has been forced to rule in the face of undeniable evidence that the actions of the NSW police on the night of 9th of February were an “unlawful use of force”.

A statement that every activist and organiser that was present on that night knew well already. What’s more exposing is the lengths police leadership have gone to resist disclosing any and all communications between the Minn’s government and themselves. The true nature of the capitalist state becomes all the more clear.

What followed was a police operation that has since generated hundreds of complaints, disturbing footage of officers using force against demonstrators, and an investigation by the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC). The events have also produced two important legal developments: the NSW Court of Appeal’s April ruling that the government’s post-Bondi protest restrictions were unconstitutional, and the recent Local Court proceedings in which solicitor Nick Hanna, representing protesters including members of the Palestine Action Group (PAG), sought access to documents concerning the police operation.

PAG has been one of the most well organised and consistent activist organisations over the past three years, making the Australian mass movement the largest anti-genocide movement in the advanced capitalist world. This new development has exposed far more than the misconduct of a handful of officers, which the established narrative tries to play these findings off as. Rather, it brings forward a fundamental questioning around what is the true role of the police and the government in capitalism.

The CCTV and body-worn camera footage undeniably proved the extent of the brutal treatment non-violent protesters were subjected to on that evening. Scenes that we had already been familiar with from the hundred angles caught on the phones of those present. Men, women and the elderly shoved, knocked over, dragged, punched while restrained and trampled under jack boots. Bones broken, and immeasurable psychological trauma.

Without a doubt it was systematic. The crackdown was clearly meant to be a lesson for the masses that dare to defy. If it weren’t so, if it really was only a few bad apples – what explains the reason the leaders have been avoiding producing subpoenaed evidence? What have they got to hide? What do they not want the Australian people to see?

Minns sought to rush through broadened police powers in the wake of the Bondi terror attack. One of the powers allowed Police to deny public protests and rallies, effectively making them illegal for a period in areas following terrorism declarations. Others were broadened powers to enforce the removal of face coverings and move on directions. Both of which have a significant impact on detracting the effectiveness of political protests.

During the Herzog rally, police utilised these new powers to arrest 27 people. What followed the event was correctly pointed out as a show of force and intimidation. After the Herzog protest – kettling, OC spray used on corralled crowds, officers dragging men from prayer, per the LECC’s own hearing outline – the premier, police minister and commissioner “have all refused to admit that any wrongdoing occurred, and rather they’ve affirmed that police did as the state requested”, despite having access to the press.

It was only when some 800 accounts of evidence flew in the face of this statement was an official investigation launched. So who’s holding who accountable here? The police subsequently launched ‘strike force Laine’, utilising Public Order Riot Squad (PORS) and Operations Support Group (OSG) teams to hunt down and arrest several other activists and protesters weeks after the event. Samantha Lee, a leading solicitor of Redfern Legal Centre aptly described the manhunt as seeming to be “a very public deterrent and a demonstration of state power… designed to punish, intimidate and discourage members of the community from coming forward to the Commission.”

Minns tried to justify the powers as being vital to protect the health and wellbeing of Australians and to maintain social cohesion following a terror attack. But what does social cohesion protect? Does it protect the lives of Palestinians from Israeli mass murder? Or does it protect the political establishment that maintains the ruling class’ power, both in Australia and Israel?

Nevertheless, Minns’ efforts were for nought. On 16th of April, the Court of Appeal shut the powers down, following the appeal presented by PAG, Blak Caucus and Jews Against the Occupation ‘48. In no small part – it should be emphasised – the combined pressure of the mass organisations, the politically charged climate, the balance of class forces, and the current period of sharpened class antagonisms likely contributed to the final ruling the court decided on.

Today, the complaints and allegations around the police operation that night in February are centre stage. The LECC’s investigations into the unlawful conduct by the police presented the video evidence in court. Amongst footage of brutal tackling, punching, excessive OC spraying and body dragging one body-worn recording captured a male officer saying gleefully boasting “I fucking pumped that cunt” while his female counterpart laughs in response.

One of the most infamous scenes from the night was the brutal treatment of a Muslim prayer group trying to practice their evening prayer. The NSW police were found to have lied in their brief of evidence. Solicitor Nick Hanna argued that the recorded evidence contradicts the police report that the worshipers were ordered to disperse prior to their prayer.

Hanna went on to argue that these incidents should not be simply reduced to the actions of a few bad individual officers, rather what must be questioned is how exactly was this police operation planned, and if the behaviour reflected the directions given by police leadership. A fair question! How exactly was it planned, and why are the leadership dragging their feet about presenting evidence?

The fact that the LECC had received over 800 complaints about this operation alone – making it the most reported incident in Australia’s history – begs the question indeed.

The latest legal proceedings primarily concern these documents that could help establish how the operation was planned and authorised. Hanna’s team has requested communication documents that involve Minns, the police minister, their staff and senior police leadership. Police Commissioner Mal Lanyon’s legal representation unsurprisingly opposed the subpoena. On 19th October Local Court Judge Scott Nash ruled that the requested material has a legitimate and important forensic relevance. Now it remains whether the police will actually present anything to the case.

And it really brings the question to everyone’s mind. Is this the true nature of policing laid bare? Is this what it is really like? I can at least give personal testament from my experience as a former police officer. The police training I received, specifically the riot training taught by the same Public Order Riot Squad reflects what I witnessed from the turmoil of that night. Verbatim, I can recall most memorably the instructing officer giving the lecture when comparing different past protests –

“Far-right protests, they sometimes are a bit full of crackpots, but generally they are protesting about ‘common sense’ issues. Far-lefties on the other hand. These are the Marxist and anarchist types. The socialists and communists. Their little hearts bleed for terrorists. These snowflakes view us cops as the enemy.” The officer would go on to say – “If protestors do everything legally. If they get approved. They follow the rules. They stick to the approved areas and route. They will have a good time. No dramas. But if they come illegally. They come prepared, with things like milk, face masks, goggles, we will make sure they learn a lesson.”

Lenin developed his explanation of the state in ‘State and Revolution’, based on Engels analysis in the ‘Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State’, which is that it is an instrument of class rule. –

The state is not simply a neutral arbiter that stands outside society, and that reconciles competing interests for the common good. It is a system of institutions through which the dominant class maintains the political order on which its economic and social power depends. 

The police are a fundamental part of this apparatus. Known as the specialised bodies of armed men and women that are tasked with enforcing the law of the dominant class, to disperse disruptive and unwanted public assemblies, and make arrests and employ physical force under legally permissible means (sanctioned social violence acceptable to the ruling class).

In this case, police have been utilised to act against the inconvenient disruptions caused by mass mobilisation against Australia’s complicity and material support for Israel’s mass murder and subjugation of the Palestinian people. These mobilisations are understood by Australia’s ruling class for exactly what they are. A growing threat to their established rule, and a threat in potential if allowed to grow and develop to become enmeshed with the organised layers of the working masses on a class basis.

Capitalism’s structural nature rests upon the reproduction of its social relations. Workers must sell their labour power to survive. Production must be organised around private ownership. Capitalist imperialism must dominate and subjugate foreign nations. Governments must protect and manage these relations and any class antagonisms that threaten their stability.

In manageable periods, workers and other oppressed layers can organise against these conditions in restraint that they do not fundamentally challenge them. The state tolerates or mediates, notably only if the economic health of capitalism in the period of question can permit. Australian capitalism today is an unhealthy beast. Its tolerance is meager. The contradiction between workers and the ruling class is clearer than ever.

The Town Hall demonstration in February brought this contradiction out for all to see. Opposition to Israel’s bloody genocide on Palestine was confronted by a major police operation under extraordinary protest conditions. These are significant legal wins made by Hanna in the court room, and the consistent and diligent pressure the activist groups maintained are good reasons to be proud. These small wins can build to galvanise the resolve of all those against the ongoing slaughter of Palestine. Rallies like these can be connected to a mass struggle, a general strike, to turn the tide in our favour.

Anti-immigrant fearmongering and anti-Arab xenophobia are front and centre these days. The bourgeois media have made it their aim to systematically portray immigration as the primary reason for capitalism’s current crises. Both right wing and right-populist parties have struggled with this question around Minns’ police powers.

On the one hand, they are both leaning heavily into the anti-immigration rhetoric, and on the other – their political base substantially rejects the overarching power of the political establishment and views those powers as draconian; hence they are struggling to present themselves as both handling the immigration question, and looking anti-establishment. This helps explain the internal fracturing on the right, with the Liberals and Nationals losing their base to Hanson’s popularity.

One thing is certain, Labor has become the despised face of the political establishment and a current emphasis for the reason there is a polarisation to the left and right. Labor’s deep unpopularity is felt by all sides. Premier Minns has been stuck operating within the leadership position of a government that is forced to manage such growing class antagonisms. He must answer to the jingle of the coin purse, and ensure that we rabble of the masses do not rattle the foundations too much – a task he has been unable to fulfill.

His growing frustration has been glaringly obvious to all. From the beginning, he openly expressed regret back in 2023, immediately after October 7, when he described listening to advice of police leadership to allow a Palestine demonstration to march to the Opera House peacefully, where he was quick to generalise the entire march as violent and anti-semitic.

One year later, Minns lamented that the consistent protests had cost the NSW police budget over $5 million. He then argued that police should have the right to refuse any demonstration on the grounds of their economic impact alone. Unions correctly pointed out how undemocratic such a power would be. Of course, the logic that follows this is that these are the drastic measures governments and police resort to when the working class does truly impact the economic foundation of the coin purse holders. Minns just expresses those frustrations quite barefacedly.

Mid-2025, Minns and the police tried to block PAG from organising the Harbour Bridge March, however the Supreme Court was forced to give it the go ahead due to PAG’s challenge. Not long after came the anti-semitic attack of Bondi and the events that followed on the 9th February.

The government is being pulled in a tug-of-war between an array of pressures. On the one hand, diplomatic and imperialist pressure with its alliance with the United States and the state of Israel. Another by the anti-immigrant and xenophobic scapegoating sentiments fermented by the conservatives and insurgent right-populists.

And importantly by the economic sickness of Australian capitalism rapidly catching up with the rest of the world mired in the current crises.

The organised masses have been correctly recognised for the danger they present to the political establishment’s perceived public legitimacy. Not just to Minns, Albanese, and Labor overall – but to any party that tows the line of complicity in mass murder and genocide. But the movement remains a threat in potentiality alone unless it organises beyond its current limitations.

Three years of demonstrations have not ended the slaughter of Palestinians. The racist, Zionist state of Israel still exists. Political inconvenience is not enough. The current government can be replaced by another, and the slaughter can continue unabated until Palestine no longer exists.

The trade union bureaucracy is too meek and cowardly to call for anything remotely close to the pro-Palestine general strike that briefly brought Italy to a standstill, but this is precisely what is needed. If trade union leadership won’t do it, then the masses should force them to! The CGIL leadership was forced to appeal to the general strike the workers and youth of Italy brought about. ACTU, which typically just mediates between the classes, could similarly then be forced to tail behind the will of the union rank and file if such an action took root. Bodies such as PAG could play a bigger role than they are currently. The ruling class’ politicians certainly do not underestimate the potential of the forces they are capable of mobilising, neither should they themselves.

The police force will continue to be used as the brutal arm of the capitalists and their lackeys in Macquarie Street and Parliament Drive. Yet the police are not the almighty power that the ruling class presents them as. The working class, when organised and mobilised at even a fraction of its incredible strength, has more than enough power to sweep away any and all repressive bodies of the state. But in order for this to happen, the working class requires a leadership that is up to the task.

The objective conditions are undoubtedly present within the country to make an actual material difference in bringing the Australian ruling class to heel with its complicity in genocide. What is not present is the subjective factor. The revolutionary leadership is still being built. The mass movement is present, however. We saw this with the numbers that turned out against the war criminal Herzog.

For now, there remains a vacuum on the revolutionary left. It isn’t sufficient to have the right ideas as revolutionary individuals. We must be organised, trained, and actively building our forces. Let us not waste any more time. This is the task that the RCI in Australia has set itself. Join us.