As the global economic situation continues to worsen and make its mark on every country in the world, political leaders in Australia are vying to put their stamp on affairs by echoing policies abroad. This applies to the whole spectrum, from left reformism to right populism, even with ‘centrist’ outfits attempting to hone their sensible and stable approach. In particular, the Greens are seemingly reorienting themselves as a sharper left flank of Labor in response to One Nation’s polling success as the ‘anti-establishment’ underdog.
This was provoked by Larissa Waters’ resignation as Greens leader due to health concerns, which has been taken by the party’s main figureheads as an opportunity to increase their influence by leaning into more Mamdani-style politics. The main contenders for the head position were David Shoebridge and Mehreen Faruqi, Shoebridge coming out on top with 7 votes against 4. Rank-and-file Greens members have voiced their dissatisfaction and called for future leadership votes to be opened up to the broad membership, something one would expect to be ABC for a ‘grassroots’ organisation.
The party’s main think tank – The Green Institute – have put forward a bold proposal worth $25 billion. With the ‘Fair Go Grocers’ plan, they are vowing to forcibly purchase 200 Coles and Woolworths supermarkets in order to nationalise them and place them under state control, in an attempt to undercut and challenge the duopoly as they continue to rake in record profits during a cost-of-living crisis. Here we will delve into what exactly is being proposed, its limitations, and the permanent solution we Communists have to offer.
Reasons for the proposal
The general purchasing power of the working class has been whittled away quicker than ever since the Covid-19 pandemic and the ensuing recession, with the menace of inflation persisting and wages having not risen in accord. All the while, the Coles-Woolworths duopoly, amongst all other monopolies spreading their tentacles over the market, have continued to rake in record profits.
According to the think tank’s analysis of annual reports by the supermarket giants, Coles’s supermarket earnings before tax had grown by 58% since 2019, while Woolworths’s had grown by 41%. Meanwhile, the cost of essential goods like cooking oils, eggs, beef and milk had risen by 45%. Simultaneously, wages have gone backwards, and even supermarket workers’ wages have failed to keep in line with inflation. This is despite the fact that Coles posted a staggering $1.09 billion net profit for the most recent financial year, while Woolworths reported net profits of $1.14 billion.
It would be difficult for anyone without a fat wallet to disagree with counter-measures being made against these price gougers as they squeeze the working class dry. A poll by YouGov, ran by the Green Institute, found that 84% of Australians support public supermarkets being rolled out in Australia. To add on, 62% of Australians (including 53% of One Nation voters!) would be more likely to vote for a party that proposed the policy.
This is a clear demonstration of the claim we made in an article outlining One Nation’s rising support, that the majority of their voter base are connecting the populist party’s anti-establishment rhetoric with their very real economic anxieties and hatred for the two party duopoly.
When Coles and Woolworths are currently profiting enough to feed every Australian child living in poverty, it’s no wonder such a policy is receiving widespread support. But can this type of change come about through parliamentary action alone?
Nationalisation or expropriation?
The defining factor of these limitations is that the Greens accept the rights of individuals to exploit labour and the market economy as a whole. This is precisely why communists demarcate themselves from this reformism. This political perspective views capitalism as an imperfect, yet essential system which only requires regulation and reforming to be brought into line with public interests. The truth is, it is a rotten system which has long exhausted its historically progressive role and which must be overthrown completely by the working class.
Trotsky’s words in ‘The Transitional Program’ on the act of nationalisation and expropriation ring truer than ever:
“The socialist program of expropriation, i.e., of political overthrow of the bourgeoisie and liquidation of its economic domination, should in no case during the present transitional period hinder us from advancing, when the occasion warrants, the demand for the expropriation of several key branches of industry vital for national existence or of the most parasitic group of the bourgeoisie.”
Communists do not oppose partial acts of reform, encroachments on private property and the profits of the rich. What we oppose is the sowing of illusions that this is all that is necessary, and that it must be left to the ‘professionals’ to carry out on behalf of the working class.
Trotsky writes again:
“The difference between these demands and the muddleheaded reformist slogan of “nationalisation” lies in the following: (1) we reject indemnification; (2) we warn the masses against demagogues of the People’s Front who, giving lip service to nationalization, remain in reality agents of capital; (3) we call upon the masses to rely only upon their own revolutionary strength; (4) we link up the question of expropriation with that of seizure of power by the workers and farmers.”
Our primary criticism is not that we are against such a reform, but that as a parliamentary decision, it relies on the working class remaining passive and dependent. The Communist program of supporting such a demand is to always expose the class question, to emphasise the importance of unified and independent workers’ organisation, and to explain the revolutionary alternative to permanently solve the crisis.
The question of compensation for taking over this property is also of mighty importance. When we step back and ask the big questions, it becomes clear what needs to happen. Who is producing the value being accumulated by the duopoly, and all capitalists for that matter? What role do these owners truly play in production? Are they necessary, or are they simply parasites sucking the blood of the working class?
When it is understood that these monopolists live by exploiting the value produced by workers day in and day out, the question of expropriation by the workers is reduced to a matter of claiming what is rightfully ours and utilising it for our own ends. At a time when these supermarket giants are making billions in profits with extortionate prices and low wages, it is an insult to suggest that they should be ‘compensated’ with even a single penny, let alone $25 billion.
Class interests
Capitalist states and their political representatives have historically carried out or retained strategic nationalisations when they suited the interests of the ruling class as a whole, but not necessarily the individual capitalists here and there. In times when a nation’s capitalist class as a whole is threatened by either war, global competition and alliance interests, or organised workers breathing down its neck, their political leaders can nationalise vast swathes of industry and increase elements of economic planning.
In particular, during and after WWII, governments extensively seized or brought private industries under state control to manage war efforts and rebuild devastated economies. This is something the proponents of the free-market shy away from discussing because it is a crushing blow to what they truly defend – private accumulation of wealth created by the labour of others.
An ongoing development in Western Australia is clearly demonstrating an instance where national security interests subordinate the individual capitalist to itself. The Australian federal government has confirmed that nationalising the Perth-based rare earths developer Northern Minerals is “one option” under consideration after China-linked investors repeatedly defied orders to divest their shares.
In May 2026, Treasurer Jim Chalmers ordered six China-linked shareholders to sell off a combined $40 million stake (representing roughly 18% to 27% of the company) by a July 2 deadline, citing national security concerns. The investors failed to comply.
Again, these economic models are based on the interests of the capitalist class as a whole and are conditioned by their own history and the world situation.
Given enough pressure from below, governments will absolutely make concessions as they see necessary to try to temper the growing class anger of the masses. From civil rights wins, to better working conditions, to Medicare, to the deposing of a ruler, history demonstrates that the people themselves hold the levers of society in their own hands, and only when correctly organised can they make massive gains.
In all cases, the central question remains, who is carrying out the nationalisation and in whose interest? With the Greens, this is undoubtedly a pro-worker policy that will certainly be struggled against by big business owners and their political representatives. Whether the party will stick to their guns and defend the proposal, or capitulate and water it down, will be conditioned by its willingness to boldly mobilise a base of support from the working class and the youth.
The supermarket bosses will not simply hand over their shops and their profits without a fight. Only a mass movement is capable of forcing concessions out of the rotten capitalist class, but the history and present approach of the Greens gives no indication that they intend to pursue this path.
Revolutionary alternative
A program such as this will require the working class to rely strictly on its own revolutionary strength rather than parliamentary deals. The taking over of key industries like food production, along with railroads, raw materials, and private banks, must be bound up with the complete transfer of state power into the hands of the working class and farmers.
Public supermarkets created by parliamentary decree – without mobilising workers and youth in a fight against the bosses, and without supermarket workers’ control over their workplaces – will immediately come under attack and be undermined by big business. Only the class struggle can solidify such gains in the short term, and only the abolition of capitalism in its entirety can guarantee them in the long term.
Our divide is our rejection of paying compensation to the capitalists and ensuring the capitalist system overall remains protected from revolutionary transformation. Reformist nationalisation where the state purchases companies at market value (or at any value) can only result in that burden being shifted onto the shoulders of the workers, rewarding the exploiters. The Communists demand outright expropriation under workers’ control, with zero compensation to the capitalists.
To carry out this historic task, we require a highly organised and professional revolutionary party that can win over the working class to this program, to concentrate its forces against capitalism to wipe it out once and for all. If you are sick of oppression and exploitation, then the Revolutionary Communist International belongs to you. Join us in the fight.

